Homemade Dog Food Toppers: 6 Easy Recipes That Make Plain Kibble Exciting Again

Six easy homemade dog food topper recipes, from shredded chicken and green beans to frozen pumpkin drops, plus the 10% calorie rule, a calorie chart, and how to batch and freeze them.

When Dodo was a little puppy, she went through a phase of refusing her dinner. I tried a few things, and the one that worked was ridiculous. I put the exact same food into Alice's empty bowl, and suddenly Dodo wanted it. Nothing about the food had changed, only the bowl it was in, which told me a lot about how much presentation matters to a dog.

That phase is long over, but it got me interested in toppers, the small spoonful of something extra you put on top of a dog's regular food. A topper can add smell, texture, and moisture, and for a lot of dogs that's enough to make a boring bowl feel new. I already wrote about store-bought toppers for picky eaters, so this post is about the homemade kind you can cook in your own kitchen with plain ingredients.

Before getting to the recipes, it helps to know how much topper is too much.

The 10% rule for homemade toppers

Veterinary nutritionists at UC Davis say treats and any extra foods should stay under 10% of a dog's daily calories, and at least 90% should come from a complete and balanced diet. 1 Toppers count toward that 10%, the same as treats and training snacks. Their example is simple to remember. If your dog eats 100 calories a day, no more than 10 of those should come from extras. 1

The reason this matters is that dog food is formulated as a full package. Tufts veterinary nutritionists point out that most recipes people design themselves or find online are missing at least one essential nutrient, and the gaps can take weeks or even years to show up. 2 AKC also cites UC Davis research that found 95% of 200 home-cooked dog food recipes lacked at least one essential nutrient. 3 Keeping a topper small means the complete food is still doing almost all of the work.

To figure out your dog's budget, check the calories per cup on your dog food bag and multiply by how many cups your dog eats in a day. Your vet can also give you a daily calorie target. If your dog eats 1,000 calories a day, the topper and treat budget is about 100 calories. When you add a topper every day, it's a good idea to ask your vet whether to trim the kibble a little so the total stays the same.

How many calories are in common topper ingredients?

I pulled these numbers from the USDA FoodData Central database, which lists calories for plain cooked foods. 7 An inexpensive kitchen scale makes this much easier than guessing with spoons, because a "spoonful" of chicken can vary a lot.

Ingredient (plain, no salt or oil) Calories per 100 g Calories per ounce
Chicken breast, roasted, meat only 165 about 47
Ground turkey, 93% lean, pan-cooked 213 about 60
Egg, scrambled 149 about 42
White rice, cooked 130 about 37
Sweet potato, baked 90 about 26
Blueberries, raw 57 about 16
Green beans, boiled 35 about 10
Carrots, boiled 35 about 10
Pumpkin, canned, no salt 34 about 10

The pattern is easy to see. Meat and eggs carry most of the calories, and vegetables and pumpkin are very light. That's why most of the recipes below lean on vegetables for volume and use a small amount of protein for smell.

Ground rules for every recipe

Every recipe here follows the same few rules, and they matter more than the exact ingredients.

6 easy homemade dog food topper recipes

Each recipe makes enough to portion out over several meals. Serving sizes depend completely on your dog's calorie budget, so use the table above to work out how much fits.

1. Shredded chicken and green beans

This one is the easiest place to start. AKC says plain roasted, poached, grilled, or baked chicken can be mixed into a dog's regular meal, and it even suggests pairing chicken with a vegetable like green beans. 4

Poach one boneless, skinless chicken breast in plain water until it's cooked all the way through, then let it cool and shred it with two forks. Boil a handful of green beans until soft, chop them into small pieces, and mix the two together. Half a cup of boiled green beans is only about 22 calories according to UC Davis, so the beans add a lot of volume to the bowl without using up much of the budget. 1

The leftover poaching water is plain, unsalted, and smells like chicken. Once it cools, skim off any fat that rises to the top, and you can pour a spoonful over dry kibble to soften it. Count it as part of the topper, since some of the chicken's flavor and fat ends up in there.

2. Turkey and pumpkin mash

Brown a small amount of 93% lean ground turkey in a nonstick pan with no oil, break it into crumbles, and drain off any fat. Stir in plain canned pumpkin. Use pumpkin puree with pumpkin as the only ingredient, since pumpkin pie filling has added sugar and spices.

Pumpkin is one of the lightest ingredients on the list at about 10 calories an ounce, and AKC says pure pumpkin can help with both diarrhea and constipation. 6 I have a whole post on how much pumpkin dogs can have if you want the details on canned versus fresh. The turkey is the calorie-heavy part here, so go easy on it and let the pumpkin carry the volume.

3. Plain scrambled egg

Crack one egg into a nonstick pan and scramble it with no butter, oil, milk, or salt until it's fully cooked. Let it cool and break it into small bits over the food. AKC says scrambled or hard-boiled eggs are both fine as long as they're fully cooked. It recommends against raw eggs because of salmonella and a protein in raw egg whites that blocks biotin absorption. 5

Eggs are calorie-dense, and AKC suggests keeping them occasional rather than a daily staple unless your vet says otherwise. 5 For a big dog like Alice, who is about 60 pounds, a small portion of one egg fits easily. A small dog might only need a spoonful, and the rest of the egg can go into your own breakfast.

4. Sweet potato and carrot mash

Bake or boil a sweet potato until soft, peel it, and mash it with a few boiled carrots. Don't add butter, brown sugar, or marshmallows. This makes a thick, orange mash that coats kibble well and portions easily into a freezer tray.

Sweet potato has more calories than the other vegetables, at about 26 calories an ounce, so this is a topper where portion size matters. 7 Carrots stretch it out at about 10 calories an ounce. If you want more on how to prepare sweet potato for dogs, I wrote a full sweet potato guide for dogs.

5. Chicken and rice spoonful

Mix a little shredded chicken from recipe 1 with plain cooked white rice. Chicken and rice is a familiar pairing, and AKC lists rice as a useful source of energy and fiber in homemade feeding. 3 As a topper, use only a small spoonful on top of the regular food. Chicken and rice alone is far from complete nutrition, and if your dog has an upset stomach, call your vet rather than switching to a homemade bland diet on your own.

6. Frozen pumpkin and blueberry drops

This one is a little different because it works like a cold treat on top of the bowl. Mix plain pumpkin with a few mashed blueberries, spoon the mix into a silicone tray, and freeze it. Pop one small cube onto the food at mealtime. AKC describes blueberries as rich in antioxidants and fiber, and pumpkin keeps the calorie count low. 6 Blueberries are about 16 calories an ounce, so a few berries per cube is plenty. 7

How to batch, freeze, and store homemade toppers

This post contains affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. I am not a veterinarian, and the product suggestions are based on what the products are designed to do.

Cooking a topper for every meal gets old fast, so it's much easier to make one batch, portion it out, and freeze it. For portioning, I like silicone freezer trays with lids, such as the Souper Cubes 1/2 Cup Silicone Freezer Molds. The tray has a lid and comes in half-cup portions, and you can pop out a single block without thawing the whole batch. For the portion you're using this week, a small airtight container like the Rubbermaid Brilliance 1.3-cup container keeps it separate from your own leftovers.

Follow the same food safety timing you'd use for your own leftovers. These guidelines come from FoodSafety.gov's cold storage chart. 8

Topper Refrigerator (40°F or below) Freezer (0°F or below)
Cooked chicken or turkey 3 to 4 days 2 to 6 months
Soup-style mixes with meat or vegetables 3 to 4 days 2 to 3 months
Hard-cooked eggs 1 week Do not freeze

FoodSafety.gov notes the freezer times are about quality. Food kept frozen at 0°F stays safe, but the texture and flavor fade over time. 8 Thaw portions in the fridge, and label the lid with the date so you're not guessing later.

Toppers also make the feeding area messier. Pumpkin mash and shredded chicken have a way of getting pushed out of the bowl and onto the floor, especially by puppies. A washable mat under the bowls means the mess goes in the laundry instead of soaking into the rug, and LoveWag washable mats are made for exactly that kind of cleanup. You can use code THECHOWDODO for 15% off.

Toppers for puppies, seniors, and dogs with health conditions

Puppies. Dodo is about 10 months old, which means she is still growing, and growing puppies are the group where nutrition mistakes matter most. Tufts says home-cooked diets shouldn't be fed to growing puppies, and AKC quotes a board-certified veterinary nutritionist calling puppyhood "the most nutritionally fragile time of life." 2 3 Adding a small topper to a complete puppy food is very different from replacing the food. Keep puppy toppers tiny, and introduce one new ingredient at a time.

Seniors. Alice turned 10 in September. AKC notes that homemade food adds moisture, which can help senior dogs whose thirst tends to decline with age. 3 Seniors can also gain weight easily, so the 10% limit still applies.

Dogs with medical conditions. If your dog has kidney disease, pancreatitis, diabetes, food allergies, or any other condition, ask your vet before adding anything. Chicken is one of the more common food allergens in dogs, along with beef, dairy, wheat, and egg. 4 If you want to cook your dog's entire diet, Tufts recommends getting a recipe from a board-certified veterinary nutritionist and following it exactly. 2

When to call the vet

Start new ingredients slowly and watch for a reaction. AKC lists vomiting, diarrhea, itching, hives, swelling, coughing, and trouble breathing as signs of a food reaction. 5 Swelling or trouble breathing needs an emergency vet right away. Repeated vomiting, a painful belly, or refusing food after a rich meal can be signs of pancreatitis, and those also need a vet visit. 10

If your dog eats something on the toxic list, such as food seasoned with onion or garlic, grapes, or anything with xylitol, call your vet or the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center at (888) 426-4435 right away instead of waiting for symptoms. 9

Frequently asked questions

Can I put a homemade topper on my dog's food every day?

Yes, as long as the topper plus treats stays under about 10% of daily calories and the rest of the diet is a complete and balanced dog food. 1 Rotating between a few recipes keeps it interesting without overdoing any one ingredient.

Should I reduce my dog's kibble when I add a topper?

If the topper is more than a tiny amount, probably yes. Ask your vet how much to cut back so the daily calories stay the same, and keep an eye on your dog's weight.

Can I use store-bought broth as a topper?

I'd only use broth made for dogs. Many broths sold for people contain onion, garlic, or a lot of salt, so read the label carefully if you try one. The plain water left over from poaching chicken in recipe 1 is a simple homemade option.

What's the difference between a topper and homemade dog food?

A topper is a small extra on top of a complete diet, and homemade dog food replaces the diet entirely. The second one needs a recipe from a veterinary nutritionist to be safe long term. 2

References

  1. UC Davis Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital, Nutrition Support Service, Treat Guidelines for Dogs
  2. Tufts Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine, Petfoodology, Should You Make Your Own Pet Food at Home?
  3. American Kennel Club, Choosing Balanced Ingredients for Homemade Dog Food
  4. American Kennel Club, Can Dogs Eat Chicken?
  5. American Kennel Club, Can Dogs Eat Eggs? Benefits, Risks, and Safety Tips
  6. American Kennel Club, Fruits and Vegetables Dogs Can or Can't Eat
  7. USDA, FoodData Central
  8. FoodSafety.gov, Cold Food Storage Chart
  9. ASPCA Animal Poison Control, People Foods to Avoid Feeding Your Pets
  10. Pet Poison Helpline, Thanksgiving Pet Safety Tips
  11. Merck Veterinary Manual, Garlic and Onion (Allium spp) Toxicosis in Animals