Crate Training a Stubborn Puppy: The Honest Timeline and What Finally Worked
Learn how we finally crate-trained our stubborn mini chowdoodle puppy, Dodo. Get the honest timeline, the mistakes I made, and the practical tips that worked.
Crate Training a Stubborn Puppy: The Honest Timeline and What Finally Worked
When we brought Dodo home in February, I had this vision of a peaceful puppy who would trot into her crate, curl up on a soft blanket, and sleep through the night. I had read the books. I had watched the videos. I had successfully raised Alice, my chow shepherd, who practically crate-trained herself nine years ago. I thought I knew what I was doing.
Dodo had other plans.
Our mini chowdoodle is smart, loyal, and incredibly stubborn. The first time I put her in her crate and closed the door, she let out a scream that sounded like I was actively harming her. It wasn't a whimper. It was a sustained, high-pitched shriek that rattled my teeth. I sat on the floor outside the crate, exhausted, wondering what I had gotten myself into.
If you are currently sitting on the floor outside a crate, listening to your puppy scream and wondering if you are ruining them forever, I see you. I have been there. We got through it, and you will too. Here is the honest timeline of how we crate-trained Dodo, the mistakes I made, and what finally worked.
The Setup: Getting the Right Crate
I started with a soft-sided travel crate because I thought it looked cozier. Dodo immediately tried to dig her way out of it, tearing a hole in the mesh within ten minutes. I switched to a standard wire crate, specifically the MidWest iCrate.
The iCrate comes with a divider panel, which is crucial. Puppies need a space just large enough to stand up, turn around, and lie down. If the crate is too big, they will sleep in one corner and use the other corner as a bathroom. Dodo was tiny when we brought her home, so I moved the divider up to give her a very small footprint. As she grew, I adjusted the divider to give her more room.
I also learned quickly that soft blankets were a mistake. Dodo would push them into a pile and pee on them. For the first few weeks, she slept on the bare plastic pan. It felt mean, but it was the only way to prevent accidents. Once she was reliably holding it through the night, I introduced a thin, washable crate pad.
The First Week: Surviving the Night
The first three nights were awful. I put the crate on my nightstand so she could see me, smell me, and hear me breathing. It didn't matter. She cried for an hour before falling asleep, woke up two hours later, and cried again.
I made the classic mistake of taking her out when she was crying. I thought she needed to pee. She didn't. She just wanted to play. By taking her out while she was making noise, I taught her that screaming opens the door.
I had to reset. On night four, I instituted a strict schedule. I took her out right before bed. I put her in the crate. I turned off the lights. When she cried, I put my fingers through the wire so she could smell me, but I did not speak to her and I did not open the door. I set an alarm for 2:00 AM. I woke her up, carried her outside, gave her two minutes to pee, and put her right back in the crate. No talking, no playing, no lights.
She still cried, but the duration dropped from an hour to twenty minutes. By the end of the first week, she was settling down within five minutes.
Building Positive Association During the Day
Nighttime was only half the battle. I needed Dodo to tolerate the crate during the day so I could work, shower, or leave the house without worrying she was chewing on electrical cords.
I started feeding her all her meals in the crate. I would put the bowl inside, leave the door open, and let her walk in on her own. Once she was comfortable eating inside, I started closing the door while she ate, opening it the second she finished.
I also used high-value treats that she only got in the crate. I stuffed a Kong with peanut butter and plain yogurt, froze it, and gave it to her when I needed her to settle. The frozen Kong was a game-changer. It took her thirty minutes to clean it out, and the licking action naturally calmed her down. Often, she would fall asleep before she finished it. We also started using the Woof Pupsicle packed with frozen peanut butter as a crate distraction, and it buys us a solid thirty minutes of quiet. Code DODO gets you 15% off.
I practiced putting her in the crate while I was still in the room. I would put her in with a chew, sit on the couch, and read a book. I wanted her to understand that going into the crate didn't always mean I was leaving. Sometimes it just meant it was time to relax.
The Turning Point
The real breakthrough happened around week four. I had been enforcing mandatory naps during the day. Puppies need 18 to 20 hours of sleep, and Dodo would not settle on her own. She would get overtired, bite my ankles, and terrorize Alice.
I started putting her in the crate for two hours in the morning and two hours in the afternoon. At first, she protested. I covered the crate with a dark sheet to block out visual stimulation and turned on a white noise machine to drown out household sounds.
One afternoon, I put her in for her nap. She didn't cry. She walked in, turned around three times, sighed heavily, and went to sleep. I stood in the hallway and stared at the crate, waiting for the screaming to start. It never did.
Where We Are Now
Dodo is now six months old. She sleeps through the night in her crate without a peep. When I grab a frozen Kong from the freezer, she runs to her crate and waits for me. She still prefers to be out with us, and she will occasionally let out a single, sharp bark if she feels she has been in there too long, but the panic is gone.
Crate training a stubborn puppy is exhausting. It tests your patience and your sanity. There were days I thought she would never get it. The key was consistency. I had to out-stubborn my chowdoodle. I had to stick to the schedule, ignore the tantrums, and make the crate the place where the best things happened.
If you are in the thick of it right now, keep going. Stick to your routine. Use the divider. Freeze the Kongs. Cover the crate. It feels endless when you are losing sleep, but one day, your puppy will walk in, lie down, and go to sleep. You will get your life back.
Our Picks from the @thechowdodo Storefront
These are products we actually use and recommend. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases — but I only link things Dodo and Alice have tested.