Best Training Treats for Dogs That Aren't Food Motivated
If you have a dog who turns their nose up at standard kibble or spits out expensive store-bought treats during training, you know the strugg...
Best Training Treats for Dogs Who Aren't Food Motivated (Yes They Exist)
If you have a dog who turns their nose up at standard kibble or spits out expensive store-bought treats during training, you know the struggle. You stand there holding a piece of dried liver while your dog stares at a leaf blowing across the street. I get it. Dodo, my mini chowdoodle, is notoriously stubborn and not food motivated. Alice, my chow shepherd, is independent, aloof, and has a sensitive stomach that makes finding the right reward a delicate balancing act.
Finding the right training treat for a picky dog is about finding the right texture, smell, and value that makes your dog decide working with you is better than whatever else is happening in their environment.
Quick Picks: The Top 3 Treats for Picky Dogs
- Happy Howie's Premium Meat Rolls Why it works: You can cut it to any size, it doesn't crumble in your pocket, and the smell is strong enough to grab a stubborn dog's attention.
- Stella & Chewy's Freeze-Dried Raw Dinner Patties Why it works: These crumble easily into a powder you can use to coat other treats, or break into tiny, high-value pieces that melt in the mouth.
- Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Dog Food Why it works: It functions as a complete meal but has the strong scent and jerky-like texture of a high-value treat, making it perfect for dogs with sensitive stomachs.
Quick Comparison
| Treat | Size | Calories | Smell Factor | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zuke's Mini Naturals | Tiny | 3 cal | Medium | Everyday training |
| Stella & Chewy's Carnivore Crunch | Small | 2 cal | High | Picky eaters |
| Real Chicken (boiled, diced) | Custom | ~5 cal | Very High | High-value recall training |
| Freeze-Dried Liver | Small | 5 cal | Very High | Stubborn dogs, outdoor distractions |
| Pet Botanics Training Rewards | Tiny | 3 cal | Medium | Long sessions, budget-friendly |
| String Cheese (torn) | Custom | ~8 cal | High | Emergency recall, high-drive dogs |
Why Finding the Right Treat Matters
Training a dog who isn't food motivated requires a shift in perspective. When a dog refuses a treat, they are communicating that the reward isn't worth the effort of the behavior you are asking for. In high-distraction environments, the value of the treat needs to increase significantly.
For dogs like Dodo, a standard biscuit won't cut it when there is a squirrel nearby. For dogs like Alice, the treat needs to be enticing enough to overcome her natural independence, but gentle enough not to cause digestive upset later. The goal is to find a reward that your dog genuinely wants, which builds engagement and makes training a collaborative process rather than a chore.
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Happy Howie's Premium Meat Rolls
These meat rolls are a staple in the dog training community for good reason. They come in a large sausage-like roll that you slice and dice yourself.
- Pros: They hold their shape perfectly without crumbling, making them ideal for treat pouches. The smell is potent, and you control the portion size.
- Cons: You have to prep them yourself before a training session, and they need to be refrigerated after opening.
- Price: Around $10-$15 for a 2lb roll.
- Where to buy: #
2. Stella & Chewy's Freeze-Dried Raw Dinner Patties
While technically a meal, these patties are incredible for training. They are soft, easy to break apart, and packed with protein.
- Pros: Excellent for dogs with sensitive stomachs like Alice. They melt in the mouth quickly, which is crucial for rapid-fire rewarding during training.
- Cons: They can be crumbly and messy in a treat pouch.
- Price: Around $40 for a 14oz bag.
- Where to buy: #
3. Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Dog Food (Mackerel & Lamb)
This air-dried food has a strong, pungent smell that picky dogs often find irresistible. The Mackerel & Lamb recipe is particularly effective for grabbing attention.
- Pros: It is a complete and balanced food, so you don't have to worry about unbalancing your dog's diet if you use a lot of it during a session. The pieces are small and flat.
- Cons: It is one of the more expensive options on the market.
- Price: Around $45 for a 2.2lb bag.
- Where to buy: #
4. Icelandic+ Whole Freeze-Dried Herring
If you need something incredibly stinky to break through intense distractions, this is it. These are literal whole freeze-dried fish.
- Pros: The smell is unmatched. It is a single-ingredient treat, making it safe for most allergy-prone dogs.
- Cons: The smell is unmatched—your hands and treat pouch will smell like fish. They are also large and need to be broken into smaller pieces.
- Price: Around $18 for a 3oz bag.
- Where to buy: #
5. Pure Bites Freeze-Dried Beef Liver
A classic, single-ingredient treat that works well for many dogs. Freeze-dried liver is a staple because it is highly palatable and easy to digest.
- Pros: Very affordable and widely available. Single ingredient makes it safe for sensitive stomachs.
- Cons: Can be very dry, which might make some dogs thirsty during training. It also crumbles easily.
- Price: Around $10 for a 4oz bag.
- Where to buy: #
6. Real Meat Company Air-Dried Jerky Biti
These are small, soft jerky squares that come in novel proteins like venison and lamb.
- Pros: The texture is soft and chewy, which many dogs prefer over crunchy biscuits. They are pre-cut to a great training size.
- Cons: They can dry out if the bag isn't sealed properly.
- Price: Around $12 for a 4oz bag.
- Where to buy: #
Comparison Table
| Product Name | Price Range | Best For | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Happy Howie's Meat Rolls | $ | Bulk training, treat pouches | 5/5 |
| Stella & Chewy's Patties | $$ | Sensitive stomachs, rapid rewarding | 4.5/5 |
| Ziwi Peak Air-Dried | $$ | Complete nutrition, strong smell | 4.5/5 |
| Icelandic+ Herring | $ | High distractions, extreme picky eaters | 4/5 |
| Pure Bites Beef Liver | $ | Budget-friendly, single ingredient | 4/5 |
| Real Meat Jerky Biti | $ | Soft texture, novel proteins | 4.5/5 |
How to Choose the Right Treat
When shopping for a picky dog, look for three main characteristics: smell, texture, and size.
Smell is the primary driver of a dog's appetite. If a treat smells like cardboard, a non-food-motivated dog will ignore it. Look for treats with strong odors. Fish, tripe, and liver are usually safe bets.
Texture matters just as much. Most dogs prefer soft, moist treats over hard, crunchy ones. Soft treats are easier to eat quickly, allowing you to reward the dog and immediately move on to the next repetition.
Size is crucial for training efficiency. A training treat should be no larger than a pea. If the treat is too large, the dog spends too much time chewing, which breaks the flow of the training session.
What I Actually Use for Dodo and Alice
With Dodo, I have to rotate treats constantly. She gets bored easily. I usually start a session with Happy Howie's because the texture is perfect for my treat pouch. If we are working on something new or highly distracting, I pull out the Icelandic+ Herring. The smell is awful, but it is the only thing that keeps her focused when she decides she would rather be doing anything else.
Alice is a different story. Because of her allergies and sensitive stomach, I have to be careful. I rely heavily on Stella & Chewy's patties. I break them into tiny pieces. They don't upset her stomach, and they are high-value enough to convince her that listening to me is a good idea. I also use Ziwi Peak as a high-value alternative to her regular kibble when we are just doing light reinforcement around the house.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if my dog won't take any treats outside? This usually means the environment is too distracting or stressful. Start training inside where it is quiet. Gradually move to slightly more distracting environments, like your backyard, before trying to train on a busy street. You may also need to increase the value of the treat when you step outside.
Can I use human food for training? Yes. Plain boiled chicken, string cheese, and plain hot dogs are excellent high-value rewards. Just ensure you are cutting them into tiny, pea-sized pieces and factoring them into your dog's daily caloric intake.
How do I stop my dog from getting bored of their treats? Create a treat hierarchy and rotate your options. Keep the highest value treats exclusively for difficult tasks or highly distracting environments. Use lower value treats for easy, well-known behaviors at home.
Final Verdict
Training a dog who isn't food motivated is entirely possible. You just have to find their currency. For most picky dogs, the Happy Howie's Premium Meat Rolls offer the best balance of high value, ease of use, and affordability. If you are dealing with a sensitive stomach like Alice, Stella & Chewy's or Ziwi Peak are worth the investment. The key is to experiment, find what makes your dog's ears perk up, and use that to build a stronger relationship.
Our Picks from the @thechowdodo Storefront
These are products we actually use and recommend. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases — but I only link things Dodo and Alice have tested.
Browse our full Amazon storefront →